Posted: Oct 27, 2008 11:54 pm
| Edited by: Schooley
Education, health care, and voting are not rights (as defined by the bill of rights).
For just one example - the constitution or bill of rights didn't say anything about slavery being wrong, either. They had to add in some kind of amendment about that later on, as I recall. Changes
have been made, from time to time. Yeah, so the "right" to health care isn't specifically outlined in the constitution. The average lifespan was also about 35 or so when that document was written, women couldn't vote, and blacks weren't considered people.
You talk about how immigrants still come to the US, and they do. But they tend to come from countries with really brutal dictatorships and corrupt governments, or that are torn by civil war, or countries with severe economic problems. Few them come from western Europe, Japan, Australia, Scandanavia - areas of the world with a more socialized economic structure, and that all happen to have universal health care. Is it really worth bragging that the US is better off than Haiti, Rwanda, Cuba, Mexico, or China? If Swedes, Danes, the French and Dutch were flocking here you might have an argument.
Every successful economy has a mix of socialism and capitalism. Even this capitalist oasis. We already socialize education, infrastructure, the military, scientific research, etc. etc. We recently socialized our entire banking system. We are already taxed heavily, yes, but most of the benefits of these taxes go to lining the pockets of the already wealthy, at the expense of everybody else. I agree that our government is bloated and needs to be reformed, but what's wrong with actually expecting something in return for all our tax dollars in the meantime?
But don't take my word for it. There's a nice little smart-ass piece in Counterpunch today, and it's by a college professor so maybe he's more credible than I am, even if I say some of the same things...
Remind Me Again - Who Won the Cold War?
But at least now we can finally answer our pregnant question: Which American president has been the most socialist of all, apart from FDR and LBJ? The (really, really) surprising answer is: George W. Bush.
...
You have to admit, it’s more than a bit odd to see the United States, that bastion of capitalism, led by George W. Bush, that great champion of free market ideology, now massively plunging itself deeply into good old-fashioned socialism in the form of increased welfare state benefits, bailouts, and the nationalization of major industries. Add that to existing programs and those coming around the corner, plus increased regulation, and pretty soon we won’t be far off from being... France! �" the nightmare scenario of those sick things on the right. Somehow, in their addled brains, when George W. Bush massively expands government healthcare coverage for seniors that’s a good thing, but, say, providing it to children or to all of us represents evil socialism, the very thing which will destroy the fiber of this mighty country. Nevermind that ‘mighty’ seems to ring more melodious in a sentence with ‘China’ these days than with ‘America’. Only people twisted enough to think that the democratic socialism practiced by contemporary Europeans is some sort of decadent system produced by Satan himself (“My god, they get paid maternity leave!! There’s healthcare for all!! They work far fewer hours per week and have guaranteed seven-week vacations!! This is just wrong!! This humanity is inhuman!!”) could also applaud Bush for doing exactly the same thing for which they’d certainly excoriate Obama for doing.